AFA Monthly logo

4 September 2019

With Jonathan Pearlman

The forgotten neighbour

Off the tip of north Queensland is a looming problem that Australia has long tried to avoid: a people suppressed. The region of West Papua receives little attention in Australia, partly because Indonesia blocks access to aid groups, foreign media and the United Nations. But Canberra, too, prefers this silence.

In recent weeks, however, the people of West Papua have shown that they don’t intend to be forgotten. Following an incident in which a group of Indonesian nationalists was filmed racially abusing Papuan students, Papuans have launched the largest independence protests in decades. 

Dozens of demonstrations have been held, some of which have resulted in deadly clashes with Indonesian forces. In Jayapura, the capital of Papua, protesters set fire to the parliament and police buildings. Indonesia blocked phone and internet access across the region and dispatched 6000 troops.

On Monday, it was reported that four Australians were being deported from Indonesia after participating in the protests. The arrests allowed Indonesian authorities to resort to their perennial claim about West Papua: that foreign forces, particularly those from Australia, are encouraging the province’s secession as a means to weaken and divide Indonesia. “We know these groups [of demonstrators] have relations with an international network,” said Indonesia’s national police chief, Tito Karnavian.

These paranoid claims are a reminder that Indonesia is an insecure archipelago, a country that consists of thousands of islands and hundreds of languages, and whose current national borders are an accident of postcolonial history. The concern among Indonesian military and political leaders is that Australia, having supported Timor-Leste’s independence (although for many years it did not), will now back West Papua, and that other countries will follow suit.

West Papua, whose people are Melanesian, has a distinctive history, and its status has never been settled. The reason to support its independence is not to destabilise Indonesia. It is to end an injustice. The region was not initially a part of Indonesia when the republic gained sovereignty in 1949, but remained under Dutch control. It was handed over to Jakarta by the United Nations in 1963, pending a vote by the province on independence. But the 1969 ballot was a sham, involving about 1000 voters handpicked by Indonesia from among a population of 800,000. Since then, Indonesia has conducted a number of brutal military crackdowns against West Papuan separatists. It deliberately moved non-Papuans into the area until the current president, Joko Widodo, ended this transmigration practice in 2015. The region now has a population of about 3.5 million, only half of whom are indigenous Papuans. It’s Indonesia’s poorest region, despite having one of the world’s most lucrative copper and gold mines – a key incentive for Jakarta to retain it.

Seeking to avoid damaging its relationship with Indonesia, Australia has rejected calls for a new West Papuan referendum. In 2006, Canberra recognised Indonesia’s territorial integrity in the Lombok Treaty, which explicitly opposed separatist movements. The Howard government had backed Timor-Leste’s independence, and now hoped the treaty would placate Jakarta.

Indeed, the Coalition and Labor, both of which have struggled to develop close ties with Jakarta, have dismissed calls for West Papuan independence as reckless. It’s been easy for both major parties to maintain this position because there is scant public discussion in Australia of the predicament in the region. But this could change, particularly if reporters are able to access information about Indonesian crackdowns, and if media outlets publish the stories. International support for a referendum could grow. And while this would not defuse Indonesian paranoia, it would help to protect Australia from being seen as the lead instigator in a push for independence. Currently, several Pacific nations support the West Papuan cause, as does British Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, who is believed to be the only leader of a major Western political party to publicly do so.

In the meantime, Australia continues to ignore the injustice in the region, even as it occurs on its doorstep. “I’m honoured to be here to celebrate these achievements,” Scott Morrison told his Timorese counterpart during a visit to Dili last week, marking twenty years since Timor-Leste’s Australia-backed independence referendum. “Your nation forged through sacrifice is perhaps the greatest achievement of all … We are pleased to have been able to play the part that we have.”


Australia’s booming trade with China will shape strategic policy

“Diplomatic relations may have been strained, but Australia’s trade relationship with China is growing ever closer. The latest trade report shows that China was the destination for a record 40 per cent of Australia’s exports in June … The most immediate risks are more economic than strategic.” David Uren, The Strategist (ASPI)

Asia’s coming era of unpredictability

“China’s latest port development projects in Darwin in northern Australia and near Sihanoukville in Cambodia demonstrate how China is filling up the maritime space at the junction of the South China Sea and the Indian Ocean, where it already has a network of ports going back to the previous decade … The Indo-Pacific is no longer a US naval lake.” Robert D. Kaplan, Foreign Policy

Timor-Leste’s future still shadowed by the past

“The tiny half-island nation – a Portuguese colony for 450 years before the Carnation Revolution saw it cast adrift, triggering a brief nine days of independence before neighbouring Indonesia’s 1975 invasion – still struggles with huge development challenges, a legacy of brutality, and leadership by an old guard who could be the grandfathers of most of the rest of their country-folk.” Sophie Raynor, The Interpreter (Lowy Institute)


Australia’s harsh immigration policy

“Australia is the only country that mandates immigration detention for all ‘unlawful’ arrivals, including those seeking protection as refugees. Australia has had one of the most punitive policies on forced migration in the world, including controls beyond the border; the current US practice of caging ‘illegal’ migrants comes close.” Claire LoughnanThe Diplomat

Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam is powerless to lead or even quit

“Ms Lam still has three years to go for her first term as Chief Executive – a role many people view as an impossible task of taking orders from the Communist Party government in Beijing while representing a city that’s deeply suspicious of China’s intentions.” Bill BirtlesABC News

Free from Australian Foreign Affairs

Common Enemies, book review by Bill Farmer

“He writes with first-hand experience, both as an officer in the attorney-general’s department in Canberra and as legal counsellor in the Australian embassy in Jakarta. McKenzie sets out to analyse the extensive cooperation on criminal justice between the two countries, and to make suggestions about strategies for future cooperation. The result is engrossing.” Bill FarmerHERE



What I hope is … we can manage to see a summit.

Emmanuel Macron, president (France)

I think [Rouhani] is going to want to meet.

Donald Trump, president (United States)

We do not want bilateral talks with the United States.

Hassan Rouhani, president (Iran)

Sources: Reuters (for Macron and Trump), Aljazeera 

Read past editions of AFA Monthly

Sign up to AFA Monthly to get each new edition in your inbox