AFA Weekly logo

18 May 2022

With Grant Wyeth

Military exercises with PNG


Last week, the Australian Defence Force concluded a two-month training exercise with the Papua New Guinea Defence Force (PNGDF), seeking to enhance PNG’s ability to respond to any unrest during next month’s election. The Australian Army’s 3rd Brigade was joined by the United Kingdom’s 2nd Battalion Royal Gurkha Rifles and the United States’ Wisconsin National Guard in training the PNGDF to de-escalate conflict and avoid heavy-handed approaches.

Elections in PNG are highly complex, due to geography, poor transport infrastructure, significant community rivalries, financial restraints, disenfranchisement of women, and difficulties with election administration. PNG’s 2017 election was particularly violent, with widespread voter intimidation, the destruction of property, and the hijacking of ballot boxes. A total of 204 people were killed in election-related violence – many as a result of excessive use of force by security personnel.

Yet conditions this year could be even more complex, due to significant loss of employment and income owing to the pandemic, a general suspicion of vaccines causing additional health concerns, and increased inflation affecting people’s access to daily essentials. These factors could heighten community tensions and make the security of the election process more difficult.

Australia and its partners – the UK and US – are obviously keen to see the election conducted with integrity and in a peaceful manner. This is essential for the development and welfare of PNG, but also for the stability of Melanesia and the broader Pacific region.

 

Biden meets ASEAN

The White House hosted a two-day summit of ASEAN leaders last week, albeit without all ten members present. Myanmar was not invited, and the outgoing Philippines president, Rodrigo Duterte, was absent because he did not want to travel to the United States “as a matter of principle”. The Philippines foreign minister attended in his place.

Understanding that South-East Asia is wary of being dragged into any strategic competition between the United States and China, President Joe Biden instead made climate change a central pillar of the summit. The leaders discussed the establishment of a new US-ASEAN Climate Solutions Hub, designed to accelerate the deployment of clean energy technology throughout the region, decarbonise the transport sector, reduce methane emissions, and facilitate collaboration with the US National Parks Service to counteract deforestation in South-East Asia.

For Australia, the summit presented a serious lesson about its own engagement with South-East Asia. Climate change poses an enormous regional security concern, but it also presents an opportunity for Australia to integrate more with its neighbours to the north. Australia can work with ASEAN on risk assessment and preparing for natural disasters, and it has the potential to be a significant exporter of renewable energy to nearby countries, such as Indonesia and Singapore.

Of course, both the United States and Australia will always have one eye on China in their engagements with South-East Asia, but the best way to project influence in the region is to take the concerns of ASEAN seriously.

 

War and wheat

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is posing a significant threat to the world’s food security. Ukraine was the world’s sixth-largest exporter of wheat in 2021, with around 10 per cent of the global export market. Due to the war, Ukraine’s grain shipments have plummeted from around five million tonnes per month to a few hundred thousand, causing a significant increase in prices.

India is the world’s second-largest producer of wheat, although its huge domestic consumption means it’s not a big exporter. Despite this, there was an expectation that India could make up Ukraine’s shortfall due to recent bumper crops, but as domestic inflation has increased, last week the Indian government – always hyper-aware of the cost of food – imposed a ban on the export of wheat. However, New Delhi clarified over the weekend that it would “ensure the fulfilment of the genuine needs” for countries that are dependent on wheat for their food security.

War has the unfortunate consequence of bringing opportunity as well as devastation. For Australia, as a major wheat exporting country, there is the potential to meet at least some of the world’s wheat needs. The Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics is forecasting an increased wheat output by the end of the 2021/22 financial year, but believes that output will drop in 2022/23, due to the likelihood of continued excessively wet weather.

Wheat is so ubiquitous that continued access to it is often rarely considered. But the protracted war in Ukraine, domestic priorities in India, and climate change-induced abnormal weather conditions in Australia have led to a convergence of negative trends that are now affecting global food security.


 


THE ELECTION SPECIALS

WEEK SIX: WHAT DO WE WANT – SELF-RELIANCE OR FREE TRADE?

This week we ask Sonia Arakkal, Tim Harcourt, Darren Lim and Erin Watson: What do we want – self-reliance or free trade? CONTINUE READING

-
-

Weekly round-up

How well has the Morrison government handled relations with South-East Asia?

“For Australia to be successful in South-East Asia, governments of both political persuasions require a more sophisticated narrative on the role of China in the region to avoid alienation from key partners. Governments must also respect the sustainable economic development priorities of South-East Asian countries on their own terms, not just as pawns in a larger geopolitical game.” Greta Nabbs-KellerTHE conversation

Will Australia and Japan move beyond the ‘Quasi-Alliance’?

“The Australia–Japan quasi-alliance has been gradually developed, mutually recognised, and recently activated. Now it could possibly evolve into a new multilateral security alignment in the Indo-Pacific era” Daisuke Akimoto,the diplomat

China’s Australia literacy – a dangerous assumption in foreign policymaking

“In Canberra’s formulation of China policy, a dangerous assumption has long been made, perhaps innocently, that sufficient Australia literacy is in place in China to avoid disastrous misunderstandings and miscalculations.” Diane Hu,asialink insights

-
-

What a Marcos Jr presidency in the Philippines means for geopolitics

“While it is difficult to predict the new administration’s foreign policy positions in any detail, due in large part to the campaign’s deliberate obfuscation, there is no doubt the Philippines represents a significant piece in the puzzle of shifting geopolitical allegiances in the region … If the Philippines slides further into electoral autocracy, only Indonesia is left flying the flag for democratic government in South-East Asia.” Adele Webb,The interpreter (lowy Institute)

How the arrival of the Amadea superyacht wedged Fiji between a Russian oligarch and the United States government

“Fiji is arguably in an unenviable position. On one side of this case is a mysterious investment company headquartered in the Cayman Islands, potentially backed by one of the richest men in the world. On the other side is the might of the US government pursuing a warrant issued in a Washington DC court.” Emily Clark,abc news

-
New from Black inc. books

The Game

Sean Kelly

What happens when the prime minister views politics as a game?

A must-read account of a man, a time and a nation.

Sean Kelly gives us the definitive portrait of Scott Morrison – a politician not quite like any other. Morrison understands that politics has become a game – one he is determined to win. He also understands something essential about Australia, something many of us are unwilling to admit, even to ourselves. But there are things Scott Morrison does not understand. This is the story of those failures, too – and of how Morrison’s approach to politics has become a dangerous liability.read more

-

GIVEAWAY

 Win one of five ebook copies of The Game

ENTER HERE
 

-

AFA WEEKLY
EVERY WEDNESDAY AT 3PM

 

Share AFA Weekly with a friend.

And subscribe to Australian Foreign Affairs, today.

-


Read past editions of AFA Weekly


Sign up to AFA Weekly to get each new edition in your inbox